HR Advice Hub
What if an Employee Says They're Fit to Work but Their Employer Disagrees?
An employee may feel ready to return to work following sickness absence, but what happens when their employer has concerns about whether they're well enough to undertake their duties?
This can be challenging, especially where the employee believes they are fit to work but medical advice suggests otherwise. Employers must balance their responsibilities for workplace health and safety with the employee's rights, while ensuring decisions are fair and supported by appropriate evidence.
Can an Employer Refuse to Let an Employee Return to Work?
There may be circumstances where an employer has legitimate reasons to delay an employee's return, especially where there are genuine concerns about their health, safety or ability to undertake essential duties. However, an employer shouldn't automatically prevent someone from returning simply because they have an ongoing medical condition or have previously been absent due to illness.
Any decision should be based on the individual circumstances, the requirements of the role and the available evidence. Employers should discuss their concerns with the employee and consider whether temporary adjustments or alternative duties could enable a safe return. Where necessary, further medical advice or a workplace risk assessment may help inform the decision.
What if the Employee Disagrees With Occupational Health Advice?
An employee may disagree with an occupational health report suggesting they are unfit for work or unable to undertake certain duties. Occupational health provides professional medical advice, but it doesn't make employment decisions on the employer's behalf. Equally, an employee's belief that they are fit to work doesn't automatically override medical concerns.
Employers should consider the employee's views alongside the available medical evidence and the practical requirements of their role. Where there is disagreement, it may be appropriate to seek clarification from occupational health, provide further information about the employee's duties or request an updated assessment.
The aim should be to understand what the employee can reasonably undertake and whether suitable support could enable them to work.
What if the Employee Has a Fit Note Saying They Are Not Fit for Work?
A fit note stating that an employee is not fit for work doesn't automatically prevent them from returning before it expires. An employee may feel sufficiently recovered to resume work earlier than expected and doesn't normally need another fit note confirming they are fit.
However, employers should consider any relevant medical advice and whether the employee can safely undertake their duties, especially in physically demanding or safety-critical roles. Where concerns remain, these should be discussed with the employee before agreeing appropriate arrangements for their return.
Can an Employer Insist on an Occupational Health Assessment?
Employers can request an occupational health assessment where they have reasonable concerns about an employee's fitness for work. However, an employee's agreement is required, and employers cannot simply force someone to attend.
If an employee declines, the employer should explain why the assessment has been requested and how it could help identify appropriate support or adjustments.
Where the employee continues to refuse, the employer may need to make decisions based on the information reasonably available. This should take account of the employee's reasons for declining and whether sufficient evidence already exists.
Does the Employer Have to Pay an Employee They Won't Allow to Work?
Pay can become a significant issue where an employee says they are fit and available for work, but their employer decides they should not return. If an employee is genuinely ready, willing and able to work, and the employer prevents them from doing so, they may remain entitled to their normal pay.
However, entitlement will depend on the circumstances, including the employee's ability to undertake their duties, contractual terms and the reasons for preventing their return. Where an employee remains unfit for work, sickness absence and sick pay arrangements may continue to apply.
Employers should avoid assuming they can automatically place an employee on sick pay simply because they have concerns about their fitness. The appropriate arrangements should be carefully considered and clearly communicated.
What Reasonable Adjustments Should Employers Consider?
Where an employee has a disability under the Equality Act 2010, employers may have a legal duty to make reasonable adjustments. Even where a condition doesn't meet the legal definition of disability, temporary changes may help an employee return successfully.
Adjustments could include reduced hours, amended duties, additional breaks, changes to equipment or a phased return to work. Employers should consider whether these measures would enable the employee to undertake their role safely and effectively.
Not every adjustment will be reasonable or sustainable, but employers should be able to demonstrate that suitable options have been properly explored rather than dismissed without assessment.
When Should an Employer Consider Medical Capability Procedures?
There may be situations where an employee believes they can continue working, but the available evidence indicates that they cannot fulfil the essential requirements of their role.
Where appropriate adjustments, support or suitable alternative employment cannot resolve the difficulties, an employer may ultimately need to consider a formal medical capability process. However, medical capability shouldn't be an immediate response to disagreement about an employee's fitness for work.
Before progressing, employers should ensure they have sufficient medical evidence, consulted meaningfully with the employee and considered whether there is a reasonable prospect of improvement.
Any decision about continued employment must follow a fair process and take account of relevant legal obligations, including disability discrimination and unfair dismissal protections.
Need HR Support?
Disagreements about an employee's fitness for work can be difficult to manage, especially where medical advice, workplace responsibilities and the employee's own views don't align.
BloomHR provides friendly, straightforward HR advice to small and medium businesses across the UK, helping employers navigate sickness absence, occupational health recommendations, reasonable adjustments and medical capability concerns. Contact us for more information.
The HR Advice Hub is intended as general guidance only. Every situation is different, and employers should seek advice based on their specific circumstances.
Looking for tailored HR support for your business? Explore our HR services page or contact us.