HR Advice Hub
Occupational Health vs GP Fit Notes: What's the Difference?
When an employee is absent from work due to illness, employers will often receive a fit note from their GP.
However, there may be situations where additional medical advice is needed to understand whether the employee can return to work and what support might be appropriate.
This is where occupational health can help. Although both provide medical advice, they serve different purposes, and understanding the distinction can help employers make informed decisions about sickness absence, workplace adjustments and an employee's fitness for work.
What Is a GP Fit Note?
A fit note, sometimes called a sick note, provides medical advice about an employee's fitness for work. Employees who are absent due to sickness for more than seven consecutive calendar days will generally need to provide a fit note as evidence of their absence.
Although commonly associated with GPs, fit notes can also be issued by other authorised healthcare professionals, including nurses, physiotherapists, occupational therapists and pharmacists. A fit note will state whether an employee is:
Not fit for work, meaning their health condition prevents them from working during the specified period.
May be fit for work, meaning they could work if appropriate changes or support are available.
The healthcare professional may suggest amended duties, altered working hours, a phased return or workplace adaptations. However, fit notes generally provide advice about fitness for work rather than a detailed assessment of the employee's specific role or working environment.
What Is an Occupational Health Assessment?
Occupational health is a specialist service that considers the relationship between an employee's health and their work. Unlike a standard fit note, an occupational health assessment can explore the employee's particular role, working conditions and how their health may affect their ability to carry out their duties. An occupational health report may provide advice on:
Whether the employee is currently fit to undertake their role.
How their health condition affects particular duties.
Workplace adjustments that could support them.
Whether a phased return or temporary changes may be appropriate.
The likely timescale for improvement or a return to work, where this can be assessed.
Occupational health can also provide an opinion on whether a condition may meet the definition of disability under the Equality Act 2010, although this is ultimately a legal determination.
What Is the Difference Between a GP Fit Note and Occupational Health?
The main difference is the level of workplace-specific advice each provides.
GP fit notes provide medical advice about an employee's fitness for work and can be used to support sickness absence and sick pay arrangements. They are issued by a GP or another authorised healthcare professional and may suggest general changes to working arrangements, such as amended duties or reduced hours.
Occupational health assessments consider an employee's health in relation to their specific role and working environment. Usually arranged through an employer referral with the employee's agreement, they can provide more detailed recommendations about workplace adjustments, fitness for particular duties and arrangements to support a return to work.
Both provide valuable medical advice, but they serve different purposes and aren't interchangeable.
What if Occupational Health and a GP Give Different Advice?
Employers sometimes receive an occupational health report suggesting an employee could return to work with adjustments, while their GP fit note states that they are not fit for work.
Neither opinion should automatically be disregarded. Employers should consider both sources of advice, discuss the situation with the employee and establish whether the assessments were based on the same information.
Occupational health may have a clearer understanding of the employee's duties, while the GP or treating healthcare professional may have more detailed knowledge of their medical condition and treatment.
Where advice conflicts, employers can seek clarification or arrange a further occupational health assessment, ensuring relevant information about the role is provided.
The aim should be to reach an informed decision about what the employee can reasonably and safely undertake, rather than simply choosing whichever medical opinion supports a preferred outcome.
What if an Employee Says They Are Fit to Work Despite Medical Advice?
An employee may believe they are well enough to work even where their fit note or occupational health report suggests otherwise. While their views should be taken seriously, employers also have a responsibility to consider whether they can safely and effectively undertake their duties.
Employers should discuss the concerns with the employee, review the available medical advice and consider whether adjustments or alternative duties could support them.
If the evidence indicates that the employee cannot fulfil the essential requirements of their role, and reasonable adjustments or other suitable options cannot resolve the concerns, a formal medical capability process may ultimately need to be considered. However, this should follow a fair assessment of the circumstances, appropriate consultation and consideration of available alternatives, rather than being an automatic response to an unfavourable medical report.
Does an Employer Have to Follow Occupational Health Recommendations?
Occupational health recommendations are advisory rather than automatically binding instructions. Employers should carefully consider the recommendations, discuss them with the employee and assess whether the suggested adjustments are appropriate and achievable.
Where an employee has a disability under the Equality Act 2010, the employer may have a legal duty to make reasonable adjustments. Not every recommendation will automatically be reasonable. Employers need to consider the employee's circumstances, the effectiveness of the adjustment, operational requirements and the resources available.
Where a recommendation cannot be implemented, the employer should be able to explain why and consider whether an alternative arrangement could provide appropriate support.
Can an Employee Return to Work While Their Fit Note Is Still Valid?
An employee doesn't necessarily have to wait until their fit note expires before returning to work. If they feel well enough to return earlier, they can discuss this with their employer. They don't normally need a new fit note confirming they are fit for work. However, employers should consider any medical advice, the employee's duties and whether there are health and safety concerns.
Where an employee has been absent for a prolonged period or has a complex health condition, occupational health advice may help establish whether a return is appropriate and what arrangements should be put in place.
When Should Employers Consider an Occupational Health Referral?
Not every sickness absence requires an occupational health assessment. For straightforward, short-term illnesses, a fit note and appropriate contact with the employee may provide sufficient information. However, occupational health can be valuable where an employer needs a clearer understanding of an employee's ability to work.
This may include prolonged or recurring absence, concerns about an employee's ability to carry out particular duties, possible disability-related adjustments or uncertainty about a safe return to work.
Before making a referral, employers should explain its purpose to the employee and identify the questions they need answered. Relevant information about the role and working arrangements should also be provided so the assessment can offer meaningful advice.
Need HR Support?
Understanding medical advice and deciding how to support an employee can be challenging, especially when fit notes and occupational health recommendations appear to conflict.
BloomHR provides friendly, straightforward HR advice to small and medium businesses across the UK, helping employers manage sickness absence, consider reasonable adjustments and make informed decisions about returning employees to work. Contact us for more information.
The HR Advice Hub is intended as general guidance only. Every situation is different, and employers should seek advice based on their specific circumstances.
Looking for tailored HR support for your business? Explore our HR services page or contact us.